Book Review of the Week: ‘The Buffalo Hunter Hunter’

Buffalo Hunter Hunter cover detail

For this installment of our weekly book reviews from Booklist, the American Library Association’s nationally distributed book and media review publication, we have a review of the remarkable horror novel, “Buffalo Hunter Hunter” by Stephen Graham Jones, first published in the January 2025 issue of Booklist. 

Enjoy.

“The Buffalo Hunter Hunter”

By Stephen Graham Jones. March 2025. 448p. Saga.

“What I am is the Indian who can’t die. I’m the worst dream America ever had.” So says Good Stab, a Blackfeet vampire who roams the Montana prairie in 1912 looking for vengeance, to Lutheran minister Arthur Beaucarne, whom he visits each Sunday to give his confession. The book is told through the journals of Beaucarne—records of the minister’s own life but also Good Stab’s confessions—as read by the pastor’s great-great-granddaughter, Etsy, a hundred years later. Jones (“I Was a Teenage Slasher,” 2024) immediately immerses the reader in his harrowing world. Tracing the Marias Massacre of 1870 and recalling the atrocities inflicted on the buffalo and the Native people, the story charts the growing explicitness of each Good Stab confession, each one increasingly tense, violent, and accusatory, while Beaucarne begins to unravel and reveal his own horrific secrets, secrets that reach across time to Etsy. A riveting story of heartbreak, death, and revenge, this remarkable work of American fiction, a thought-provoking tale filled with existential terror, unease, and a high body count, transforms, in Jones’ deft hands, from the unapologetic horror novel it most certainly is into a critique of the entire idea of the United States—a critique that, despite the horrors, both real and supernatural, is forcefully infused with both heart and hope.—Becky Spratford

Buffalo Hunter Hunter cover detail

About Booklist

Since 1905, Booklist has published thousands of book and audiobook reviews each year, helping library and education workers decide what to buy and how to guide patrons and students of all ages in choosing what to read, view, or listen to.

We’re proud to share these reviews with you each week. If you’d like to read more—along with must-read lists, author interviews, and top reading recommendations for adults, youth, and audiobook lovers—you can enjoy a free subscription to Booklist Reader, Booklist’s magazine for library patrons, as a benefit of becoming a Supporter of the American Library Association. What could be better?

How you can support libraries

With library funding being gutted and censorship on the rise, supporting libraries is more critical than ever. If you’re looking for a way to help, we urge you to become a Supporter of the American Library Association by donating. 

At the American Library Association, we are here to protect libraries — today and for generations to come. What does your donation do? It helps a neighbor gain skills to start a business. It helps a child discover themselves through books and programs. And it helps keep libraries strong, open, and free for everyone.

Become a Supporter

Help us fight back. Your donation powers our advocacy on behalf of libraries and library workers everywhere.

Subscribe to the I Love Libraries newsletter! You’ll get news from the library world, advocacy updates, author interviews, book lists, and more delivered to your inbox every month.

Related Post